Text Only  |  Skip Navigation  | help
Birmingham City Council
Home | A-Z index | What's new? | What's on? | Jobs | Contact us   
Business and Economy Community and Living Education and Learning Environment and Planning Health and Social Care Leisure and Tourism Transport and Streets Your Council
Search:
or try our advanced search
 
  Printer Friendly

Consultation Portal
BMG report on Best Value Survey Methodology
 

Postal Survey method may further disadvantage disadvantaged groups.

Previously the Council has been required by Government to undertake a Best Value survey every 3 years to provide information about how it is performing against nationally-set indicators.

In the last round of Best Value surveys Birmingham City Council commissioned BMG Research to undertake both the statutory postal survey, and the same survey using a face-to-face interview method.

Subsequent analysis of the data has been undertaken to explore whether or not the requirement to conduct resident surveys using the “postal” methodology disadvantages certain groups.

The analysis clearly shows that the postal methodology significantly and systematically disadvantages those in poor neighbourhoods, non-white residents, the unemployed and younger people (aged under 45). In contrast, the face-to-face methodology, to a large extent, improved these effects. Disadvantaged groups were able to make themselves heard more effectively under the face-to-face methodology.

In terms of poverty, the wealthiest residents are more than 80% more likely to have their views heard under the postal
methodology than the poorest residents. This difference is reduced by a factor of four by using the face-to-face methodology.

However, the Government is now proposing a new 'Place Survey' (which will replace the Best Value Survey) be carried out every 2 years - and its most-favoured option is for it to be a postal survey. The Council will be making strong representations to try and change its mind.


Attachments
The links below go to files which are "attached" to this page.
There is a page of advice, to help you open and read attachments.
BMG report on methodologies BMG report on methodologies
 
Last updated - Monday 28 January 2008 Return to Top | Printer Friendly